So if we don't get what we feel is the proper homage in one thread, start another one and demand a different result from the unwashed masses?
*snicker*
Oughta know better than that 'round
these parts - or anywhere else on the net, for that matter....
especially when there is such a large body of tangible, verifiable evidence out there contradicting the opinion we're stating.
Lookit, the factory HP manifolds were definitely worth some power over the previously used log style ones, of that there is also no doubt - but they lose out to about any header out there you wanna use instead, super duper bone stockity-stockity engine or what have you.
They were chosen by the manufacturer then primarily for the reasons KD already stated - they were more likely to generate less warranty issues, they gave more clearance (and therefore were easier on the assembly line) and generally were a COST consideration (unit cost of production) over headers.
It was pretty cool they used them at all, really - Chryslers' famed engineers won at least a partial victory there.
Now, if the question was ever if they
should be used by any owner now on a stock engine??
I'd suggest once again that the decision is being made every day, again using the same criteria as the factory did - cost versus return on investment, performance gain versus pain in the *** once in the car (and even getting headers in the car to begin with), life expectancy once installed, originality a factor?
All those figure into everyone's
individual decision....
I enjoy the hell out of FBBO, I really do. It's gotta be the best concentration of knowledgeable "experts" on these cars of anywhere to be found on the net - and what someone doesn't know, they usually can come up with supporting documentation for and bring to us here on the forum.
I had a wise old engineer boss several decades ago who gave me some great advice:
"You don't need to know everything in this line of work, Ed - but you better know someone who does."
Dude could find any code, formula, design guide on anything at the drop of a hat - he had strong Google-Fu skills way before there was even a Google to search, real old school book, manual, documentation searching skills and a hell of a Rollodex full of numbers for those experts in whatever he needed at his disposal.
I emulate him to this day - I love the search feature here on FBBO and wish to hell people would utilize it more. I wear out GIS, the browser search feature, hell ANY search feature.
I'm big on
knowing, not guessing, not "feeling", when it comes to decision making on what to do with a physical thing in this world.
Wife says I research **** to death before we buy anything, whether it's a car, home improvement, appliance, doesn't matter - I don't go until I'm pretty darn sure what I'm going after first, exactly.
The chasing is most of the fun in it for me....just like in life, it's the journey, not the destination so much.