Comparing Classic Car Insurance Companies

[oldchevelle541]

Would appreciate opinions or experiences in comparing Hagerty vs Grundy companies. I may suggest at least IMO that Hagerty customer service people have always been friendly and helpful over the phone. I am checking with Grundy and they send me a 13 page proposal to review and sign and even though I filled out the application for insurance before hand their written proposal shows the minimum amount of insurance allowed hence (no kidding) price looked initially lower. I sent it back and asked them to quote me apples to apples.

Thoughts ??

 

[RR Fan Dan]

American Modern

 

[69L48Z27]

I left Hagerty years ago. NCM Insurance with an American Modern policy here in PA. Agency is easy to work with but I never had a claim. Prices are very fair for agreed value policies IMO. They also understand some late model cars can be collectible which is what drove me away from Hagerty.

 

[AR67GTX]

Any carrier who is underwritten by American Modern is my favorite. Insurance availability is a State by State thing so it takes some investigation. I have American Modern through Midwest Classic Car Insurance. Also the National Corvette Museum offers classic car insurance for any classic car and has excellent reputation and rates. I mean if you can please the old Corvette guys 100% it has to be good. They offer American Modern in States that it’s available.