in ANY ammeter charging system the ammeter is the LAST device in the charging circuit before you reach the battery.
EVERY load should be connected to the alternator side of the ammeter and ONLY the battery positive should be electrically connected to the other side of the ammeter.
With the system wired in this fashion, the ammeter ONLY measures the current flowing into the battery and not the total output of the alternator. On a fully charged battery, this current should be an amp or so and no more.
EVERY other "load" on the charging system is supplied to said loads PRIOR to the current flowing through the ammeter so, after the initial surge in current flow seen after the starter motor has partially depleted the battery, the ammeter will settle back to nearly zero as there should only be a trickle charge going into the battery.
If you have a heavy load on the alternator whilst running the a-c on high, the high beams on, the wipers going full tilt, etc., the alternator will be working overtime keeping up with all those loads BUT the ONLY time you'll see anything to indicate how heavily you are taxing the alternator is when the engine comes to an idle and the ammeter reads negative because the battery is, now, satisfying the loads that the alternator can't keep up with at an idle so the ammeter is showing you the reverse current rate.
So, the ONLY time you should see a pronounced positive needle reading with the engine running is if you are charging a partially depleted battery OR you have everything turned on except the engine, in which case, you'll see a negative reading.
Now, why would you see a high positive reading after starting the engine?
1. You have a bad cell in the battery. Charging it overnight just leaves an easily-depleted surface charge on the battery. To measure the battery without a load tester, first check the voltage at the battery THEN turn on the headlights for about 45 seconds AND THEN take another reading on the battery terminals. If the reading is suspiciously lower, replace the battery.
2. Your starter is drawing WAY too much current, possibly due to worn starter motor bushings and is depleting the battery to a greater degree than normal during the starting operation and your alternator will charge up the battery visible as a pronounced positive position of the ammeter which will slowly move back to just positive of center.
3. You have severely corroded bulkhead connector terminals, probably because the protective coating at the terminals has long-ago deteriorated and allowed moisture to get into the connection and corrode the terminals.
4. You have an aftermarket wiring harness without any protection on the terminals and they've corroded.
Temporary fix for corroded bulkhead terminals:
Remove the connector and pop out the terminal(s) and dip them in muriatic acid for a minute or two the wash them off with water. Carefully squeeze any loose female terminals to allow them to grip the male terminals tighter then snap the terminal back into the connector.
To remove a female terminal from the connector, place a tiny screwdriver into the open end of the terminal (there's a small notch in the connector for access to the locking tab) and carefully bend up the locking tab (seen above on the bottom of the terminal) and slide the terminal out. Carefully bend the locking tab back down before re-inserting the terminal into the connector.
The male terminal can be removed by carefully bending the pointed tang back towards the main body of the terminal and sliding the terminal out the back of the connector. Don't forget to bend the locking tang back before re-inserting the terminal.
When you're finished, pack the outside (under-hood side) terminals with heavy grease to prevent moisture from entering the connection and corroding the terminals.