We got a winner!
Almost 350 guesses on April 2025's giveaway thread and @SlingLow nailed it in post #345!
Congratulations!
The correct answer was "The Wizard" by Uriah Heep
Man ...with nearly 4,000 guesses in a row, I was sure that @Armyvet25 had this contest sewn up pages ago.

Congrats @SlingLow ....and thanks to Nick @PlymCrazy
