• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Clearance issues with 7 blade "hemi" clutch fan and my radiator. Need another fan choice.

You and me, bro. But, if you have a modified engine with a thicker core radiator, the short clutch is the solution. Got one in one of my cars !
But WHY do you think you need a "thicker" core......modifications to the engine do not dictate the size of the radiator....unless its an aftermarket aluminum unit being touted "it'll cool an xxxx hp engine" by the vendor.. now here comes the pusher o puller electric fans....up dated alternator systems, all solutions to fix nothing.....except a perceived need.......just my opinion.......
BOB RENTON
 
I really don’t enjoy beating a (dead horse). I have commented on this before.
I usually only comment on what I know. If not I relate what I have heard from people I respect.
Our personal experiences.
1993 we decided to attend a TDC Meet in Aurora Missouri.
Our son has a 67 383 PP1 Charger white hat 383 auto. 22” rad. We had it redone locally and had it 3 cored. 4 blade stock fan. No shroud. Engine was just finished.

We had our L code 67 auto Charger, 26 inch rad. 4 blade fan, no shroud. Pulling a crank up camper trailer.
We went through Kansas City, sat in long line ups to cross the river. We drove in heat around 100 degrees. Neither car overheated.
Many years ago a very well known rad shop owner said that the vast majority of overheating problems were caused not changing the antifreeze often enough. Block gets partially plugged. His recommendation at that time was. Use distilled water and change the coolant every 3 years. Flush the block.
This applied to daily drivers.
Totally agreed!!! :rolleyes:
The OE vintage mopar cooling systems were overdesigned...
Today the majority of reported issues for cooling is due to faulty engine tuning and/or mismatch of cooling components.
Some will install an aftermarket aluminum radiator that has fewer and/or smaller internal tubes, or wrong pulley.
Then many times one will add some electric fans without realizing How Much Current they draw?? And end up overloading the electrical system..

Just my $0.02... :thumbsup:
 
Its got to be a status thing. Something like chrome valve covers create hp. Last I know we are still allowed the send our allowance any way we see fit. But to spend it and then complain because something didn't work? There has been enough research to fill rooms on this stuff and people still refuse to read and believe. But we just got to have this new stuff regardless the cost.
Yes there are things worth investing in. Don't get me wrong there. But fixing something that doesn't need fixing just sounds wrong.

Ok rant over for today.
 
Totally agreed!!! :rolleyes:
The OE vintage mopar cooling systems were overdesigned...
Today the majority of reported issues for cooling is due to faulty engine tuning and/or mismatch of cooling components.
Some will install an aftermarket aluminum radiator that has fewer and/or smaller internal tubes, or wrong pulley.
Then many times one will add some electric fans without realizing How Much Current they draw?? And end up overloading the electrical system..

Just my $0.02... :thumbsup:
Some (many, if not all owners) have no real knowledge of how the Mopar cooling system operates or what criteria it was designed and believe on the "seat of the pants" engineering principles and apply aftermarket parts based on some magazine article or buddy or vendor at a trade show and those owners NEVER ask for calculations for the equipment being purchased. Just like the analogy of chrome or aluminum valve covers, enhance appearance but not performance. ........ because, everyone knows aluminum radiators are best.....???.....then bitch about clearance dimensions or lack of performance......but i guess that's human nature ......and ...yes this horse is definitely DEAD.....until it gets resurrected........just my opinion........
BOB RENTON
 
But WHY do you think you need a "thicker" core......modifications to the engine do not dictate the size of the radiator....unless its an aftermarket aluminum unit being touted "it'll cool an xxxx hp engine" by the vendor.. now here comes the pusher o puller electric fans....up dated alternator systems, all solutions to fix nothing.....except a perceived need.......just my opinion.......
BOB RENTON
WHO SAID I THINK YOU NEED A THICKER CORE ?? Bob.... thermodynamics was one of my core curriculum for my degree, so don't try to bamboozle me. I'm conversing with a member. And if you think a modified engine does not need to address the cooling system, then you don't know what you're talking about.
 
WHO SAID I THINK YOU NEED A THICKER CORE ?? Bob.... thermodynamics was one of my core curriculum for my degree, so don't try to bamboozle me. I'm conversing with a member. And if you think a modified engine does not need to address the cooling system, then you don't know what you're talking about.
A lot depends on the quantity, in terms of Btu/hr, temperatures of both the in/out of the heat source, temperatures in/out of the heat exchanger, the velocity of the coolant circulated and waste heat generated (assume 80% heat generated performs usefulwork, not waste heat)....what are your design parameters?? I too, studied thermodynamics as a component of my degree as well. I'm not trying to bamboozle you......sure, a modified engine needs a cooling system DESIGNED to handle a specific waste heat...not arbitrarily accepting the "recommendations" of some vendor......a "thicker core" is somewhat arbitrary and meaningless unless surface area (regardless of construction materials, number and size of the tubes in the tube sheet), velocity of the coolant thru the heat exchanger tubes and air temperatures both in/out of the air stream and the CFM of this air volume, with ambient temperature factored in.......and......to what degree of performance is needed or expected ...... possibly assuming a 90% efficiency???? There are several software programs that will help make those determinations....or....Mathcad, permitted the user to write their own formulas to solve the problem.....perhaps, you've heard of Mathcad.....just a thought.......
BOB RENTON
...
 
1748920712322.png
 
Why are so many people changing what the factory did for ever. If things were that bad Chrysler might have gone bankrupt! As I have have mentioned in different posts, we have stock numbered radiators in our cars. Did 3 core a 22 inch, doesn’t have a shroud, runs fine. Have a completely stock original 26” shroud and clutch fan again runs very well.
They have been run in 100 F.
A fellow that used to have a rad shop years ago, told me that if you change your coolant every two years things would last longer. (This was in daily drivers at the time). If the whole system is clean/flushed things should be fine.
These are my experiences.
BUT, those early engines mostly didn't put out the h.p. that we are getting out of our engines , some of us , twice the h.p. ...
 
But WHY do you think you need a "thicker" core......modifications to the engine do not dictate the size of the radiator....unless its an aftermarket aluminum unit being touted "it'll cool an xxxx hp engine" by the vendor.. now here comes the pusher o puller electric fans....up dated alternator systems, all solutions to fix nothing.....except a perceived need.......just my opinion.......
BOB RENTON
Disagree , more h.p. creates more heat !!!
 
Disagree , more h.p. creates more heat !!!
WHY?? Show us yout calculations or suppositions that support your premise....But all the "extra heat" generated does not go to cooling system......if your engine produces 800 hp, does all that power go to the radiator???? Or to make the car go faster??? In what form is the extra heat categorized?....parasitic losses?.....what were your design parameters? Do you know??........
BOB RENTON
 
Disagree , more h.p. creates more heat !!!
I was mainly making my comments on fairly stock driver’s. My question, hopefully someone more knowledgeable could explain it.
If I am driving on the Interstate at 70mph in a 375 hp 440, is that going to cool differently than than the same engine producing 500 hp. Gearing and everything else being the same?
 
I was mainly making my comments on fairly stock driver’s. My question, hopefully someone more knowledgeable could explain it.
If I am driving on the Interstate at 70mph in a 375 hp 440, is that going to cool differently than than the same engine producing 500 hp. Gearing and everything else being the same?
What's the final gear ratio and engine RPM for both examples?? Assume both specific are the same, the cooling requirements SHOULD be the same. Regardless of what wax or oil used or spark plugs used or tire pressure ..... if two factors are same thing, then they are equal to each other......an old plain Geometry true-ism.......just a thought.....
BOB RENTON
 
I was mainly making my comments on fairly stock driver’s. My question, hopefully someone more knowledgeable could explain it.
If I am driving on the Interstate at 70mph in a 375 hp 440, is that going to cool differently than than the same engine producing 500 hp. Gearing and everything else being the same?

in 1969 , I bought a new 440, 4 speed coronet rt , the cooling system was not even up to the task of cooling that at times , such as city traffic in Okla. heat , double the h.p. on that engine and see what happens ! If you think big h.p. engines don't require better cooling , Ive got some swamp land in Florida for you !!
 
in 1969 , I bought a new 440, 4 speed coronet rt , the cooling system was not even up to the task of cooling that at times , such as city traffic in Okla. heat , double the h.p. on that engine and see what happens ! If you think big h.p. engines don't require better cooling , Ive got some swamp land in Florida for you !!
Yup. The more HP an engine makes, the more heat is generated. To say otherwise is silly, and demonstrates a lack of knowledge of thermodynamics. If someone says otherwise, they must've FAILED that course. More heat of an engine is lost, than is used to produce power, which requires a cooling system adequate to dissipate the added heat. Don't take my word people, I'm a dummy, just look it up.
 
Last edited:
No one has answered my question in post 51.
in 1969 , I bought a new 440, 4 speed coronet rt , the cooling system was not even up to the task of cooling that at times , such as city traffic in Okla. heat , double the h.p. on that engine and see what happens ! If you think big h.p. engines don't require better cooling , Ive got some swamp land in Florida for you !!
What did your R/T have for a rad? Did you have antifreeze in it?
Let’s try to make it simpler 275x15 on a 8 inch rim. 3:23 gears. Factory 4 speed or auto. No a/c. Driving at 2600 rpm.
 
Last edited:
Auto Transport Service
Back
Top