I think tight is good. After a few minutes of running, it won't be as tight, and will have more and more play as time and miles go by. New ones are usually difficult to install. Everything has to be lined up perfectly. I usually put the cam in, with the top sprocket bolted on, aligned so the sprocket mark is straight down. This makes it easier to put the cam in. Then remove the top sprocket, put the #1 piston at TDC, and put the chain and sprockets on together, with the marks aligned. The alignment may still not be perfect, especially with a new chain. So I slide the assembly on, and put a cam bolt in finger tight, then rotate the crankshaft back and forth until the top cam centers on the cam dowel and the bolts align. Then I bolt it all up and double check the timing marks alignment. Good luck!