Need help with starter

[rduckert]

I have recently bought a 1969 plymouth roadrunner. The starter was going out so I ordered a new one. What I got was a new light weight starter. After putting it on I could hear it popping out and spinning but the engine didn't Crank. Looking through the flywheel cover I can see it was not reaching the flywheel tried another with same results and a third. Napa said it is the right starter. Any thoughts?

 

[davek]

compare the nose of the old one to the new one.

 

[retractable]

I could not get the original starter from NAPA or Auto Quest. Both sent the new style starter
I did not install any but had the original rebuilt.
Hope you can find a starter.

 

[1967coronet]

I have recently bought a 1969 plymouth roadrunner. The starter was going out so I ordered a new one. What I got was a new light weight starter. After putting it on I could hear it popping out and spinning but the engine didn't Crank. Looking through the flywheel cover I can see it was not reaching the flywheel tried another with same results and a third. Napa said it is the right starter. Any thoughts?

Welcome to a great sight.
Post in the welcome wagon and introduce your self,
We will need pics also, we like pictures.
Back to the starter.... so what did they give you ? Our local napa the kids head starts to smoke if you hit him with anything pre 90s.

 

[rduckert]

The nose is the same. The starter gear will not pop out far enough. Wondering if anyone else had this problem. I am hoping the old starter can be rebuilt.

 

[Cheapsunglasses]

Get a starter for any 90s dodge v8. It’s an easy to get cheap mini starter

 

[davek]

The nose is the same. The starter gear will not pop out far enough. Wondering if anyone else had this problem. I am hoping the old starter can be rebuilt.

do you have Advance Auto or Oreillys Auto? could order from Summit Racing

 

[1967coronet]

I just was on the napa sight
Oem style rebuild is $68.99 exchange
# RAY2441083
Or the mini or Dakota style
164.99 new, # NRO4N6415

What part number did they sell you ?

 

[rduckert]

This is the old starter I took off. Napa seems to think it is a marine starter.

 

[davek]

This is the old starter I took off. Napa seems to think it is a marine starter.

View attachment 1506469

nope that a car starter, CHRYSLER STARTER OEM # 2095219 | eBay

 

[rduckert]

But I don't see 1969 roadrunner on the list

 

[Fran Blacker]

This is the NAPA starter I used, no problem. Had to remove plastic cover where wires mount. Edit automatic trans.

 

[rduckert]

At this point I am thinking the starters from napa was the right starter but something is different on the car

 

[1967coronet]

Powermaster 3257 Powermaster OEM-Style High-Torque Replacement Starters | Summit Racing
Here is a oem style at Summit.
We're in Iowa are you rduckert ?
I'm west of Des Moines in Panora.

 

[WileE]

Do you have a rebuilder in your area ? Get the starter rebuilt.

 

[rduckert]

But if the starters from napa was the right starters and if there was something changed on the car then those won't work either. I need to find out what that is.

 

[pnora]

I have recently bought a 1969 plymouth roadrunner. The starter was going out so I ordered a new one. What I got was a new light weight starter. After putting it on I could hear it popping out and spinning but the engine didn't Crank. Looking through the flywheel cover I can see it was not reaching the flywheel tried another with same results and a third. Napa said it is the right starter. Any thoughts?

Post a picture of the starter you bought. My bets it was not fitting the bell correctly.

 

[rduckert]

I am hoping I can get the old starter rebuilt.

 

[rduckert]

It was 244-1083. But I took it back to napa

 

[Fran Blacker]

Had a little trouble getting nose of starter into bellhousing, tight fit.