IIHS FINDS FLAWS IN ACTIVE DRIVER ASSISTANCE FEATURES

General Discussion

  1. Richard Cranium

    Richard Cranium FBBO Gold Member FBBO Gold Member

    Messages:
    18,010
    Likes Received:
    33706
    Joined:
    Feb 20, 2012
    Location:
    Socialist Republic of Taxachusetts
    Local Time:
    6:19 AM
    Advanced safety systems show promise but still need improvement

    Over the past few years, driver assistance features such as automatic emergency braking and lane keep assist have become increasingly more common. But how effective are they? According to a recent study conducted by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), these features still aren't substitutes for actual human drivers, and the results varied significantly from brand to brand.

    During the study, IIHS senior research engineer Jessica Jermakian and her team evaluated the driver assistance technologies in five vehicles—a 2017 BMW 5 Series, 2017 Mercedes-Benz E-Class, 2016 Tesla Model S, 2018 Tesla Model 3, and 2018 Volvo S90. All vehicles were rated Superior by the IIHS on the front crash prevention test when equipped with front crash prevention technologies.

    2019-Volvo-XC40-pilot-assist.jpg
    VIEW 3 PHOTOS

    On a controlled test track, the researchers put the cars through four tests to evaluate their adaptive cruise control systems. In the first scenario, each vehicle was driven at 31 mph toward a stationary target to test automatic emergency braking performance with adaptive cruise control off. Only the Teslas failed to stop in time. When the same test was performed with adaptive cruise control on, all cars were able to avoid the target. Researchers noted, however, that the Volvo S90 braked later and more abruptly than the other cars. In the third test, the cars had to follow a vehicle that slowed to a stop, something all five test vehicles were able to do smoothly. When the test vehicles followed a car that changed lanes to reveal a stopped vehicle, the Volvo again slowed down more abruptly than the other four vehicles.

    On the road, the safety systems showed more inconsistencies. All cars except the Model 3 failed to respond to stopped vehicles ahead of them, and the Mercedes-Benz E-Class only detected a stopped truck at a traffic light for a short time before losing sight of it. "At IIHS we are coached to intervene without warning, but other drivers might not be as vigilant," said Jermakian, in a release. "ACC systems require drivers to pay attention to what the vehicle is doing at all times and be ready to brake manually." IIHS researchers noted that the Model 3 had a tendency to brake unnecessarily and counted 12 different times where it did so for oncoming traffic and vehicles changing lanes. Jermakian noted that unnecessary braking could pose a safety risk in heavy traffic especially if it's more forceful. Due to the systems getting confused easily, the IIHS study concluded that adaptive cruise control systems require drivers to stay attentive behind the wheel.


    The second active safety feature that IIHS looked at was lane keeping assist. Using real roads, the team put the cars through traffic, hills, and turns to evaluate each system's performance. All five cars offer steering assistance on roads with clear markings and can use the vehicle ahead as a guide at low speeds or when lane markings are blocked. Between the five vehicles, only the Model 3 stayed in its lane during all tests while the Model S overcorrected during one run, which caused it to cross the inside line of the turn. The Mercedes-Benz E-Class stayed in its lane nine out of 17 times but disengaged during one run and crossed the inside line twice. The Volvo S90 crossed the inside lane eight times while the BMW 5 Series only stayed in its lane three of the 16 runs and was the most likely to disengage instead of steer outside the lane.

    The Model S, S90, and 5 Series all came up short when hills were added to the equation. The 5 Series had a tendency to steer toward or across the lane line and even disengaged steering assistance in certain conditions. As a result, it failed to stay in its lane in all 14 of the hill trials. Tesla's Model S was only able to stay in its lane in five of the 18 trials and had a tendency to swerve left and right when going uphill until it found the correct place in its lane and rarely warned the driver to take over as it was struggling to center itself. The Volvo S90 stayed in its lane for nine of the 16 trials, with the car crossing the lane line twice and disengaging steering assistance four times when it was cresting hills. The system automatically turned back on once lane markings were detected, however.

    2017-Volvo-S90-pilot-assist.jpg
    VIEW 3 PHOTOS

    But not all test vehicles were as confused by hills. The Mercedes-Benz E-Class stayed in its lane 15 out of 18 times and provided steering assistance without many erratic moves when the car wasn't able to see lane lines. Meanwhile, the Tesla Model 3 only drifted out of its lane once when it hugged the lane line. IIHS researchers noted that some of the vehicles had a tendency to follow slow-moving vehicles into the exit lane. This is due to the lane keeping assist system using the vehicle in front as a guide instead of the lane lines at lower speeds. The IIHS sees a big potential for lane keeping assist systems to save lives but the evidence isn't as pronounced as it is with adaptive cruise control and forward collision avoidance technologies. Lane keeping assist system have the potential to save 8,000 lives per year, according to the IIHS, while lane departure warning systems have been credited with an 11-percent drop in sideswipe and head-on collisions, as well as a 21-percent reduction in injury rates for those accidents.

    Research and evaluations will continue as the IIHS moves toward making a rating system for active driver assistance features. David Zuby, chief research officer at the IIHS, says that the organization isn't ready to say which automaker has the best implementation of active driver assistance tech and stresses that none are able to drive autonomously in a safe manner. "A production autonomous vehicle that can go anywhere, anytime isn't available at your local car dealer and won't be for quite some time. We aren't there yet," said Zuby.

    https://www.motortrend.com/news/iih...84DB626347F8E087BDB2EF9577EEF79504F89C51B50C3
     
    • Thanks! Thanks! x 3
    • Like Like x 1
    • 69a100

      69a100 Well-Known Member

      Messages:
      4,261
      Likes Received:
      4972
      Joined:
      Aug 22, 2012
      Location:
      The Real World
      Local Time:
      4:19 AM
      Why are they still spending money on this shit? I will never ever get into a car that's not driven by a actual human being!
       
      • Like Like x 2
      • Agree Agree x 1
      • WileERobby

        WileERobby FBBO Gold Member FBBO Gold Member

        Messages:
        5,002
        Likes Received:
        5193
        Joined:
        Sep 15, 2009
        Location:
        State of insanity
        Local Time:
        7:19 AM
        "Warning, warning, Will Robinson !! Get the f$&K out of my way "
         
        • Like Like x 3
        • Agree Agree x 2
        • oldbee

          oldbee FBBO Gold Member FBBO Gold Member

          Messages:
          5,941
          Likes Received:
          5005
          Joined:
          Oct 15, 2011
          Location:
          NE Ohio
          Local Time:
          7:19 AM
          Memory seats. I get in by myself & the ‘puter thinks it’s my wife and my knees are crushed in the dash. TOO much!
           
          • Like Like x 2
          • Agree Agree x 2
          • cryplydog

            cryplydog FBBO Gold Member FBBO Gold Member

            Messages:
            1,002
            Likes Received:
            731
            Joined:
            Apr 13, 2013
            Location:
            NE, MO.,
            Local Time:
            6:19 AM
            They need to make a car with twin hydrostats!:thumbsup:
             
          • Don

            Don FBBO Gold Member FBBO Gold Member

            My Photo Garage
            Messages:
            627
            Likes Received:
            1104
            Joined:
            Dec 31, 2012
            Location:
            North Carolina
            Local Time:
            7:19 AM
            I surely hope they perfect these features because there are a lot of people behind the wheel these days that don't have their minds on safe driving.
             
            • Agree Agree x 1
            • JB400

              JB400 69 Charger FBBO Gold Member

              Messages:
              1,496
              Likes Received:
              845
              Joined:
              Feb 16, 2018
              Location:
              Left field
              Local Time:
              6:19 AM
              No one holds my hand when I go to the restroom. Why do they think I need it to drive? What's keeping me from falling in?
               
              • Agree Agree x 2
              • Photon440

                Photon440 FBBO Gold Member FBBO Gold Member

                Messages:
                7,458
                Likes Received:
                4994
                Joined:
                Mar 14, 2012
                Location:
                Surrey, B.C. Canada
                Local Time:
                4:19 AM
                Thanks for the read, interesting stuff. But if they wanted to, they could do another study and end up with:
                "Human drivers show promise but still need improvement".
                 
                • Agree Agree x 2
                • funknut

                  funknut Well-Known Member

                  Messages:
                  475
                  Likes Received:
                  468
                  Joined:
                  Jul 29, 2015
                  Location:
                  Cincinnati, OH
                  Local Time:
                  6:19 AM
                  It will be a good while before they can build generalized tools to handle every traffic condition, but they are making solid progress. I may not live to see a truly self driving car, but I’d take one that could cruise the interstate.

                  We did 4K miles on road trips in July and Aug. would have been nice to leave the driving to the robots. ;)
                   
                • Richard Cranium

                  Richard Cranium FBBO Gold Member FBBO Gold Member

                  Messages:
                  18,010
                  Likes Received:
                  33706
                  Joined:
                  Feb 20, 2012
                  Location:
                  Socialist Republic of Taxachusetts
                  Local Time:
                  6:19 AM
                  In other words, those who buy self driving cars and those who are going to be killed or injured by them are all guinnea pigs.
                   
                  • Agree Agree x 2
                  • Officer Higgins

                    Officer Higgins Well-Known Member

                    Messages:
                    407
                    Likes Received:
                    395
                    Joined:
                    Jun 23, 2018
                    Location:
                    Whiterville
                    Local Time:
                    7:19 AM
                    Won't be allowed to drive one day, it will be declared too dangerous, harmful to environment. Everyone needs to live in urban area together in perfect harmony.

                     
                    • Agree Agree x 2
                    • Officer Higgins

                      Officer Higgins Well-Known Member

                      Messages:
                      407
                      Likes Received:
                      395
                      Joined:
                      Jun 23, 2018
                      Location:
                      Whiterville
                      Local Time:
                      7:19 AM